Congratulations to the Cheetahs on their convincing victory over Leinster in Bloemfontein’s Free State Stadium 38-19.

This game is bound to be used as a yardstick to compare the Pro 14 to Super Rugby. The Cheetahs have had a mixed start, but this victory will make people sit up and notice. The Cheetahs never threatened in Super Rugby, but here they are beating Leinster. Even at this early stage, the experiment of South African club inclusion into the Pro 14 appears to be working.

Leinster has been a major force in European club rugby for the last two decades. They have been European Champions three times and Celtic champions four times. This is not something to be sniffed at. They were also unbeaten this season heading into the match with the Cheetahs.

Leinster legends Brian O'Driscoll and Gordon D'Arcy celebrate with the Heineken Cup. Photo: Steve Bardens
Leinster legends Brian O’Driscoll and Gordon D’Arcy celebrate with the Heineken Cup.
Photo: Steve Bardens

Compare this with the Cheetahs who only won 4 Super Rugby games this season and were badly beaten in Ireland by Munster and Ulster. At home, in the Pro 14, they have won both of their games, including a 54-39 victory over Italy’s Zebre.

Weakened Leinster

On Wednesday, two Leinster players Isa Nacewa and Jamison Gibson-Park were sent back to Ireland by South Africa customs. They are both New Zealand passport holders and did not have the required visa. The Irish passport holders do not need a visa. It truly is becoming a global game but is a lesson that needs to be taken on board. This was poor from the Leinster backroom staff.

Also, the Cheetahs were not facing the strongest of Leinster teams, even outside the customs issues. Leinster were missing two locks (second rows) as their wives are close to having babies. Add to this their mounting injury crisis, and you can paint your own picture. Among those ruled out through injury were Dan Leavy (ankle), Rob Kearney (hamstring), Jamie Heaslip (lower back), Richardt Strauss (knee) and Garry Ringrose (shoulder).

Deserved Cheetahs

Regardless of personnel, the Cheetahs deserved their bonus point victory. They executed a solid first phase game, a powerful pick and go, and showed speed in the backs. Their defensive game has improved significantly during the first four games in the Pro 14. In their first games in Ireland, the defence seemed disorganized and unable to handle the tactical difference between the two hemispheres. This has changed. It will be interesting to see what it is like when they return to Europe.

We now have the first opportunity to make direct comparisons between southern hemisphere rugby clubs with their northern hemisphere counterparts. In this case, a top European rugby club has been beaten by a Super Rugby team whose best season was 2013 when they were 6th. I think the Pro 14 is well worth watching this season.

Aside from the rugby, I do hope the crowds in South Africa get larger or the stadiums get smaller. The 7,000 spectators looked lost in Bloemfontein, but perhaps that will improve as confidence grows?

Is it a one-off? Will other European teams send stronger sides? Will the Cheetahs be taken more seriously? What are your thoughts on this victory for the Cheetahs?



Author: John Francis


  1. This was the only prediction I got right on the weekend. For me the Cheetahs were always almost a feeder team for the other SA Super franchises, every year they developed players only to lose them to the other bigger franchises. Now I think the PRO 14 will be the best thing for Cheetahs rugby, I think the PRO14 will attract players that would prefer to play in Europe, also it is a different style of Rugby that would attract a player with different skill set.
    I watched the Scarlets game on the weekend and the Rugby was very enjoyable, I had not watched PRO 12 before but now that the Cheetahs are in it, the Rugby is world class. Also it is a different type of Rugby compared to Super Rugby.

    • I hope you have enjoyed the Pro14 as much as I have this season. Mixed fortunes for the South African teams but the Cheetahs have certainly silenced the critics in the English press and the Southern Kings have had a number of really close games, even if the tables don’t look that way.

  2. With the Cheetah’s only needing a point from their game this weekend to guarantee their place in the play offs it certainly seems that they have had a good season in the Pro14. Given the length of time they have been playing without a break this is a major achievement and I expect both South Sfrican teams to do well next season. Do you think the experiment has worked?

  3. I have not been able to see the full games here in the USA, I do follow UK podcasts. The comments from the press suggest that the South African teams have been difficult to beat at home and they are perceived as fast and exciting in attack. Many people consider it a big success and look forward to next season. One comment I heard from a South African commentator was there have been concerned about northern hemisphere teams using it as a place to sign players.
    I personally believe that close contact between northern and Southern Hemisphere teams can only be good for the game. Everyone involved, including referees, benefit from these games. Also it is important to note how much the Italian clubs have improved with the new format of two pools.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here